America's New
Traditional Neighborhoods
by James Constantine, PP
 |
This watercolor of a fictional traditional
neighborhood, Nolen Park, was created to demonstrate the fabric and form of a
model TND.
Design and rendering by Peter J. Musty. |
Ever since World War II, Americans have loved the suburbs. In the late 1940s,
thousands of simple, affordable homes were built in places like Levittown, New
York. In these suburban homes, returning veterans and their families realized
the American dream of owning a home. In the suburbs, parents could raise their
children in a pristine place away from the congestion of the city.
Today,
 |
Adhering to zoning codes alone gives suburbia an
unnaturaleven unearthlyappearance. Here, a water tower hovers
menacingly above bland houses in Woodbury, Minnesota.
Photo by Richard McLaughlin. |
Americans are taking a second look at the legacy of Levittown. Commuting to
work and chauffeuring children can cut into the time available for family
activity. Some home buyers, discouraged by the choices of homes in new
developments, complain about the "cookie-cutter" appearance of houses along
suburban streets.
A growing number of developers, architects and planners are creating an
alternative to the suburb. They have looked to the past and found lessons in
the small towns and villages of America. The idea is to revive key ingredients
of old towns in the hope that new communities will blossom.
"We're
 |
A street in Fairview Village, Oregon.
Photo by Jason Miller. |
trying to create friendly neighborhood settings that foster the bonds of
community through daily casual contact," says Elizabeth Plater-Zyberk, a
Florida-based town planner who, with her husband Andres Duany, heads
Duany Plater-Zyberk & Company.
Applying principles that wed community building with contemporary lifestyles,
pioneering planners such as Plater-Zyberk and Duany are creating America's new
traditional neighborhoods. Insiders call them Traditional Neighborhood
Developments (TNDs). These developments represent a vision for a humane,
civilized place to live.
This
vision is shared by a new breed of developers. One of them is Henry Turley, who
wanted to build a new community similar to the Memphis neighborhood where he
grew up. Turley's childhood home was in an established part of the city, not
far from downtown and within walking distance of stores and shops that offered
all of life's necessities. The houses were simple but solid, built in the
classic architectural styles common in the 1920s.
"Right there in my neighborhood," Turley says, "there seemed to be
everythinga hint of all of life's possibilities mixed in with all kinds
of people. It was all within walking distance."
Turley
found investors who shared his vision and built
Harbor Town, an award-winning development on an island in the
Mississippi River, near the heart of Memphis. He had no idea that other
developers were pursuing similar projects until he read an article in 1988.
"Until that point," he says, "we thought we were the only ones trying something
like this."
During the 1980s, the first TND wave included such notable projects as Seaside,
Fla., and Kentlands,
Maryland. Each of these developments had its own distinctive style, setting and
approach. Yet all shared the goal of building more than just rows of houses or
a gated community surrounding a golf course. These new neighborhoods share a
special character based on the patterns of the past.
Corner
 |
Steeple Street shops in Mashpee Commons,
Massachusetts.
Photo courtesy of W. L. Dennis Architects. |
stores, tighter setbacks, service lanes and carriage houses are some of the
elements borrowed from historical models such as Charleston, S.C., and
Alexandria, Va., and from 1920s planned communities such as Mariemount, Ohio.
In an updated version of American small towns and historic neighborhoods, TNDs
integrate a variety of housing types, front porches, garageless streetscapes
and street networks that invite pedestrians. As a result, the residents walk
more and socialize informally in neighborhood squares and along the narrow
streets.
A
 |
Rowhouses line this neighborhood square in
Kentlands, Maryland.
Photo by Neil Takemoto, World Idea Networks.. |
sense of community begins with the neighborhood squares, which serve as places
for impromptu socializing. Surrounding the squares is a mix of homes, which
accommodate everyone from singles to seniors and first-time home buyers to
empty nesters. There are detached homes for families, cottages for retirees and
townhomes for young professionals. Sometimes various types of homes are mingled
on a single street, which makes for a varied and interesting streetscapea
far cry from some new subdivisions, which are dominated by look-alike houses
and garage doors.
Traditional
 |
Plan BC-1700 reminds passersby of the simple homes their
grandparents owned. Inside, an updated floor plan responds to modern
lifestyles.
Photo byBill Coburn. |
neighborhoods are the perfect setting for architecture reminiscent of Grandma's
house. Some of the timeless elements include floor plans designed for
day-to-day living, as opposed to maximum sales impact. Classic vertical
proportions are used for entrances, windows and columns. Dignity is achieved
with balance and restraintno single element screams for attention.
Contemporary home designs are not barred, but each community has design
guidelines that promote architectural harmony.
The goal is to create an entire streetscape that is as attractive as any
individual house. Locating homes closer to the sidewalk allows residents
sitting on their porches to converse with passersby. Porches are often
complemented by flower boxes and picket fences. Garage doors are recessed or
hidden. Narrow, tree-lined streets encourage cars to move slowly, which makes
the neighborhood safer and more inviting for pedestrians.
When
all these elements are combinedneighborhood squares, front porches and a
mix of residentsthe result is small-town social interaction, reminiscent
of Norman Rockwell paintings.
"My children are safe in this neighborhood because my neighbors know them,"
claims Janet Wood, a resident of
Harbor Town. "This concept is great for kids, because they have an
entire neighborhood to play in, rather than being confined to only the
backyard."
Traditional neighborhoods also create a physical setting where residents can
comfortably acquaint themselves with people they might not otherwise meet. "I
really know my neighbors" is a comment heard repeatedly from residents of new
traditional develpments.
A
 |
The residents of Port Royal, S.C., broke with U.S.
Postal Service standards and built this post office to blend with their
traditional community.
Photo by Jason Miller. |
traditional neighborhood has conveniences many have forgotten. Friendly,
walkable streets encourage residents to stroll to neighborhood shops. Most TNDs
do their best to include places of employment and civic institutions such as
post offices, schools, houses of worship and day-care centers.
Providing shopping, jobs and community services within convenient walking
distance allows residents to meet some of their daily needs without driving.
This provides mobility and freedom to all residents, from 8-year-olds who can't
drive yet to 80-year-olds who don't drive any more.
Offering
 |
The classic façade of plan HUB-3-E is a fitting complement to traditional
neighborhoods. Its contemporary interior lives for today.
Photo courtesy of WHA Architecture and Planning.
|
 |
The arbor and clock tower (in background) in
Northwest Landing, Wash., frame a large green that handles crowds and
one-on-one chance meetings equally well.
Photo courtesy of Michael Seidl Photography.
|
residents the opportunity to commute to work on foot has scored points with
some environmentalists, who see traditional neighborhoods as a solution to
suburban sprawl and overdependence on cars.
These new neighborhoods aren't for everyone, however. Home buyers who want to
spread out on acreage with no neighbors in sight will find such developments
too crowded. Some people bridle at the design guidelines and covenants that
sometimes constrain what they may build.
Still, the rapid emergence and growing popularity of TNDs suggest the basic
concept taps into a reservoir of yearning and unmet needs among the home-buying
public. Even the Walt Disney Company is getting into the act. Its new
traditional neighborhood, Celebration, has a town center, a public school, a
golf course and a population of 3,000. Celebration and like efforts are sure to
inspire the creation of more TNDs. Maybe one of them is right for you.
Editor's note: Portions of this article appeared in the summer 1996
issue of Better Homes & Gardens' Home Plan Ideas.
James
Constantine is the director of planning and research for the
Princeton office of Looney Ricks Kiss.
He is a licensed professional planner with extensive experience in the fields
of urban design, master planning, historic preservation, community relations
and qualitative research. With planning experience that spans more than 20
states and Canada, Jim has worked with developers, builders, and government
agencies on projects ranging from downtown revitalization to multi-modal
transit hubs. Jim has also worked on the research, planning and community
relations for numerous Smart Growth, Traditional Neighborhood Developments and
New Urbanism projects throughout North America.
Jim is a regular speaker at national and regional conferences, including the
American Planning Association, the Urban Land Institute, the
Congress for the New Urbanism, the National Smart Growth Conference,
the National Home Ownership Summit and the National Association of Home
Builders. Nationally, he has served on NAHB's Land Development Committee and,
at home, he has served more than a decade on Princeton's Historic Preservation
Review Committee.
|
|